- Author / Uploaded
- Matthias Jakob
- Oldrich Hungr
Debris-flow Hazards and Related Phenomena (Springer Praxis Books Geophysical Sciences)
Debris-¯ow Hazards and Related Phenomena Matthias Jakob and Oldrich Hungr Debris-flow Hazards and Related Phenomena
687 5 27MB
Pages 795 Page size 198.48 x 295.68 pts Year 2010
Recommend Papers
File loading please wait...
Citation preview
Debris-¯ow Hazards and Related Phenomena
Matthias Jakob and Oldrich Hungr
Debris-flow Hazards and Related Phenomena
Published in association with
Praxis Publishing Chichester, UK
Dr Matthias Jakob Senior Geoscientist BGC Engineering Inc. Vancouver British Columbia Canada Professor Oldrich Hungr Earth and Ocean Sciences Department University of British Columbia Vancouver British Columbia Canada
SPRINGER±PRAXIS BOOKS IN GEOPHYSICAL SCIENCES SUBJECT ADVISORY EDITOR: Dr Philippe Blondel, C.Geol., F.G.S., Ph.D., M.Sc., Senior Scientist, Department of Physics, University of Bath, Bath, UK
ISBN 3-540-20726-0 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York Springer is part of Springer-Science + Business Media (springeronline.com) Bibliographic information published by Die Deutsche Bibliothek Die Deutsche Bibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliogra®e; detailed bibliographic data are available from the Internet at http://dnb.ddb.de Library of Congress Control Number: 2004117082 Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, this publication may only be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms should be sent to the publishers. # Praxis Publishing Ltd, Chichester, UK, 2005 Printed in Germany The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a speci®c statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Cover design: Jim Wilkie Project Management: Originator Publishing Services, Gt Yarmouth, Norfolk, UK Printed on acid-free paper
(Matthias Jakob and Oldrich Hungr)
! "#"
$ % #
$ &
(Oldrich Hungr) (# # ) ) +# % #
' ' *
(Nigel A. Skermer and Douglas ,
"# - # # + /"
+ + ! " + # 0 1 + # 2 ! 3 $ # $ + # $ + 5 6 "" 7389 : ; " !" ) +# % #
F.
VanDine)
$ $ & . ' * * & . ' ' 4 4
$ $ $$ * *$ & & &$ &&
# $ % & !
! (Kyoji Sassa and Gong hui Wang) $ ,
"# $ >
$ $ ! $ 3 " )@ J# "# # 7 ) @ > ) ; " @ '. 0 :@ C# " @ ;@ C* B@ ? 7 / !## @ ! 9 > )@ ;" )@ ; " @ C$+ !*@ ? . +? 8 .4$@ >!+
>! 7 # !" )@ ; $4 *@ 9@ :! '**@ @
? B & , " : " - /
@ +#) !## @ A8 ; &@ "@ !#" *44 @ A% ? , " : " - /
@ +#)
!## @ A8 ; &@ "@ !#" *44 @ A% ? $
4..* 5 ) 3@ " @ + '$4 '@ >!+
? : ) 9 @ 9 % @ 44 3 " % @ 1 @ ;@ C' */'@ ? 6 7 # !## @ > ) " )@ A ; .44@ #" #@ 1 B ? C D +" 9 ## ! #
+# M /
@ ; $&@ $4 ! " @ +"
#? D
; *@ ! ) :@ $ : @ 8L# /; $@ 7 @ 93 @ >!+ ? 7! )? C >! 7 # !" )@ ; $4 *@ 9@ :! '**@ @ 8 .4$@ >!+ ? 6 C 7 ) @ 9 #0 > ) ; @ :# + **@ $ $ ; @ 7 ) ? D # C !" 7 # + @ 9# N !# > N ! @ C A + @ @ .44 ; @ ,) ? E
+ , " : " - /
@ +#) !## @ A8 ; &@ "@ !#" *44 @ A% ? + + , " "6 + 1" @ ;"# 1" @ > 6 "6 ; "" @ A 5 ! .@ '4 0@ +" ? F + / 8# !## @ > ) ; " @ * ' ! %@ C# " @ ; " @ C* B @ ? 1 #? >! 7 # !" )@ 44 !/ @ O44@ C# " @ 0+ '.*. @ >!+ ? # 7 9 C*B +'@
;7 / ,#@ $444 $ - ! @ C# " @ ;@
? $ 7 -) "# 8# / @ 1 2" > )@ - " % @ &44@ ? 1 9 + 0+ '.*. @ >!+
>! 7 # !" ) 44 !/ @ O44@ C# " @
? + >! 7 # !" )@ $ :( % @ : A @ + ' 4$@ >!+ #? G , " : " - /
@ +#)
!## @ A8 ; &@ "@ !#" *44 @ A% ? 7 &
7P 7P 7P P 3@
>! 7 # !" )@ 44 !/ @ O44@ C# " @
#? . # / 8# !## @ > ) ; " @ * ' ! %@ C# " @ ;@ C* B @ ? # # . , " 7 # M 1"# !## 3@ A8 ; 4 *. 3 -"@ 1 B #? 6 # : ) 9 @ 9 % @ 44 3 " % @ 1 @ ;@ C' */'@ ? 6 ? >! 7 # !" )@ # C # 8 )@ 44 !/ O44@ C# " @ 0+ '.*. '$.'@ >!+ ? 1 !" 7 # + @ 9# N !# > N ! @ C A + @ @ .44 ; @ ,) ? 1 9 ;82> > ) 1" % " # + 3 !## @ ! "#" / 1" - @ , "
: " % / @ A 5 ! .@ +'4 C@ +" ! 9 % # , " 0!3@ 1" - @ 0 @ ! % # : @ -.'4 ; @ ! ? 1 6? 9 % # + # A
@ > ! > )@ 3 @ > . 4@ >!+ #? 6 1 C4% Q4@
7 + # 3@ * ;
% @ 7 @ ;@
? E88 . 2) > )@ A % # , "@ % # 3 @ 7 @ >I@ *44 2) @ 5 ? 2 . 44 *@ >!+ ? E #? . 0+ '.*. @ >!+
>! 7 # !" )@ A8 ; $4 *@ @ 8 .4$
>! 7 # !" )@ 44 !/ @ O44@ C# " @
? 1 . 2) > )@ A % # , "@ 2) > )@ 7 @ >I *44@ 2) @ 5
; .9 ! " @ A8 ; .&@ . 3 % @ 2@ ;@ C4- 24@
0 C 7 # / 3@ *& 0
+"@ C# @ ;@ C.! 0@
? 7 0 >! 7 # !" )@ 44 !/ @ O44@ C# " @ 0+ '.*. @ >!+
? C? 2 2) > )@ A % # , "@ % # 3 @ 7 @ >I *44@ 2) @ 5
? G 2 , " : " - /
@ +#) !## @ A8 ; &@ "@ !#" *44 @ A%
? C D? 2 39 >! 7 # !" )@ $ :( %@ :! '4@ : A @ + ' 4$@ >!+
#? G ! + 9 # '$ # " # &* !# #
# # " #
D
?
# 3 @ , @ #
# # ) ; " ,% " # #
3 " I# 9" * A "
" # , # )
" ) +" : " "#
"
)
" ,!+% # )
? ?" ?' ?( ?* ??/
? ? ?
?
? ?
? ? ?"
? ? ?
?
? ?" ?' ?(
?*
# ) # # "# " 3
+9: # "@
" : " ! - = # 7 +9:
" # # # 4 #
" " # ," " +#FFE
(
#"
# # # # " A , ) ) D E , @ " ) " # " # " # # # # ) " ( , # " # " ( #" J # ## " ) # (## # # #" @ "
# " ) # @ ) @
J #"
) ## # ) # ) " #
# " $ #" ) 1. D F2. ; 0 ;+).
) !) D'4E ( #(# ) - ( ' ( #
"
@ #
) " " #
@ @ " @
# %# # " ) @ # # $4 44X + "
@ # #) # ) " @ # . # " # " " # # @ " # >= 44)
) #" # ) ; D'.$E@ 2 3 D''.E # # # . & ) " #" )
/ 1G @ '&.'. A " ) " "J
'*' D2)@ '*'E RR )== " )
# ) 0 0 ,, D' $E #" " # ) >! 7 # !" ) >! 1 % # "# +## ; -
D'.'E RR 1 == A " ) 3 + " .$@ .$@ .*.*@ .&..' @
.
V
' @ ' ' 1 T = ) ' @
3 + @ #" "
" " 4 ## # ) " ) (
" " ""@ @
" " ) ) : # " " ## ; "I" % @ # ) 3 + ") 9
# I" D/ @ ' *E / #" #
3 + " ' @ #" D3# = #"
) ## #" ) E , # ) " " >!U4* ##) " ## 3 + ") " ' @ D- # (@ '*E :) ) ##
# "
# D9
@ '$'E : " ) "#" ##"
" " !!%
" # @ # 2 = # " # #) ! : " @ #" # ) )
) , ! @ # #) 2 # & D9 + E@ " ) +) #) ) # I DC) )E " .$ " %" , 2 # @ " # %" #) " ) " ) @ " @ # + % @
7 D; )E 3 D:)E + #
!# $W
?" '
C ) ## " @ # @ # # "
) @ @ ) @ # " ##" ##" 9 @
)
# # , # #"A#(# @ # @ # # " $4@444 ) , ) @ +
D " '.$E A" D A ''E ##"
) # ) ?"?
%# "# J# ) # ) + # 3 ;
+ " ! 7 # # "# " D:# ) - @ 444E # # ## + &' " : " C "" 1 ,) " # A - #""@ " " 4 ## )
"
) ) #) " # " ) L#" # ?"?
6
, + # @ # #"A#(#@ "# # #" ; ) #@ ) # # # )@ ( "
A #P # :# ) " ##"
" @444 )
I " " @444 ) ) @444 ) " " " # D! @ '''E ## # #
A #P@ # #"
) 1 @ % 3"#@ A@ "#@ 5:@ !@ -; D'.E 1 ! ( ! 0 D, #" 1 ..$&@ *$ E >! , @ ;" " : @ 0 @ : )@ %+ D'E 1 I D 4 E -) ;
@ 3 : " @ D'''E 6/ 1 2 0 , D& E ! A" #) @ ) :# )@ 90 - @ 9 D444E & ) -7 , - 9 :3 . 2 -F D7!+ !# A 1 $E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8 :#A@ 5+ D'.'E 1 # D& E 9
! " 7
"@ 1 T :) + #@ - D'$*E I , . - , D+ ! # 7 P# 1# / ! 1 E ! # 7 P# 1# / ! @ ! ! V ! W :@ 3 D.'.E 8 T
* 0 . @ "@ ** 4 : @ 9 D' E
P " @ " P " =N P N I " B7 ! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !# @ 5; D''E " DRR ==E 7" 2 5 . ) @ B0DQE@ ! @ @ + @ :@ :# @ 53@ 8 @ 5 D''*E % ## # A #@ :# ? A ) "" H . @ D$E@ '' 4 ! @ @ !# @ A@ >
"9"#"#@ 5 D'''E : A #
A # # @ #"@ # :# . @ D4E@ $$4$* ! @ 1+ D'.4E + ? + ; " H 1 * - @ *@ ' ! @ 1+ %" @ !8 D''.E . 8# 1 * - @ "@ ! @ 5/@ - @ 70@ !" @ 7@ ! @ 3 D''E -
) '.4 -, . @ *DE@ & . ! #@ A D'.&E A # @ '@ .4.$ ! @ 05@ A @ %3@ @ +9@ @ + D.'&E % # ) % ) " ! #) # 2
) 4 * @ *@ &$$4. !#"@ A D'&'E 0 # "" !"6
7 " -" D & )3 & ( , D* E +" A
@ ; !"6
@ 7 ) V 7 W !)@ 5 D'4E C 0 # > @ ;"#"@ , "# @ +" D ) : 5 1+ ! @ ! (@ /;+ / " @ ' E !" @ + D.&4E - & DC E " @ A V 9 #W !" @ 0 D' E + "
)
) - # (& @ :) @ $*$* P )@ / D.'E 3 1 3 + 3 A )#T @ +! D'&'E
# " ; = ) + % '&& . L - M@ *@ D , 2 * @ *DE@ $.*4E B@ : - " " @ D'*$E "" : 2" D/ 5 , E I 8 @ *@ &*.
! ! William Savage and Rex Baum
?
;61F @6F;
, ) # ) " ##"
# 9" " ) " " # D @ E " # # "# )
# 9 ## ##@ "# @ @ ) # )
"" , 9" #" " # # #" " " # # ) @ @
" @ @ @ ) # " ,
" @ # #
# ) " 9@ )@
"
" " " #@ @
"
# " ) ) )
# @ " @ )@
# " # % @ " #
# ( ) " # 0 # ) # " ) + # ) # @ ( " # # : # )@ (
"# " ##"
@
@ " ) ,# # # #
" # " ) "# + " #) # #" @
"
@ # ##"
:) '. @ ") #" " #
# D5 @ 444E + " " " # #" @ @ @ @
# )@ # 9"
? .,
!!
!# W
$$
-)
" S
)
#
3
" S " #
% " " ! "
"
)
#
#
"
A
A
#
# # S ) ) ! #
D ?? ! # " # "# " # "" + D'&$E
# ) I ) #
" ) )
# 9 # " "# D # 9" E ) " # ! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 0
@ 35 D'&&E #
" ( @ @ . . ' 0 @ A3@ + @ :7@ 3 )@ : D44E + )
# "# # - * @ (@ .$'& 0 @ :@ -##@ 0 D'.'E %"# " ; ,? * /6 0 1 ! - 3 3 /OQO D * '* E ++ ; @ %
" # $ % & !
! Kyoji Sassa and Gong hui Wang "?
;61F @6F;
" # RR == # " ) @ # ) #
" # " @ #"
# ) )
# # D@ A @ ''4E@ ##"" D@ @ '&.@ ''E@ " # @ )
D@ 5 @ '. S ! @ '.$S / 9@ '.&S , @ ''&E # " # @ #@
") , # @ ) #
" @ " D 0 @ '. S ! @ '.$@ 444S ! : @ '..S 5 @ '.'S 0# @ '.'@ 444S &E 0
@ "
# ) "
# D! @ 444E
# "
# ) -"# ; D'&E
" "
##"
: " > " ! " I # @ "
"
" # )
##"
# D! @ '.$E
"# # "
# # " ) )
"
: 5 8 -" D E@ &' ( ) * + # A ! ; - 44$
.
# $
"?
V $
@; 1;) F ;C FD 6+) 6F11);6 )F.6.
0 # #
@ !7! 0 % " # @ 8( % . F*4*@ C E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+
4
# $
V $
#@ 0/@ %"@ !3@ 0 @ 5 D'.&E 8 ? B
)@ ) - *4 2 * 1 , 3 D,+-! A" # 1 *$@ & &E , + # -)
# !## @ #" #@ 1 B /@ ! 9@ %0 D'.&E :
@ ! 9 # # ;) ,? 5/ 79 0# D E@ ! (", 2 * 3 3 D7!+ % / 7 ) 1 &@ 4E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8 -"# @ 5 ; @ % D'&E > @ " # " . B 8 @ D E@ $ $. , @ %:@ %@ :/@ 3-" @ %7 D''&E
, ( - * @ "@ .$ . 5 @ %0 D'.'E " A" %# ,? +A !#" %0 5 D E@ * - A * D7!+ !# A 1 *@ '$$E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8 5 @ +: D'. E ,? ; " ; A D E@ 0 D $& *E 5 0) M ! @ 1 T 5!// D''E * , D5 ! #) /
/ ! ! 1 *@ **E ! @ ) V 5 W 2) !)" 3 D''&E 7 D!# " 7 @ 4 E 1 L-M@ -D4E@ *4 *&4 V 5 W 2 @ - D''&E , /OO> 3 # * 3 ! ( D% 7 + !#(# % # ''*@ A
I# 1 4. 444&@ E 2) > )@ ) : "@ -@ ! @ 8@ 0 @ 1 D''&E 7
* #
''*@ 5 # (@ /@ * A @ @ 5@ %5@ " @ 5@ ;
@ + D''4E A "
# ) 1 '.$ " 1 %"@ @ # 1. D F2
#
# ) ( )
# #
@ " # ## ) @ # ) ) " + " ) " @ ) J
"
# " #" ) ) " ## D@ # " @ " )#)@ " "#E , "#
# " ) # )#
+ @ " : 5 8 -" D E@ &' ( ) * + # A ! ; - 44$
4*
$
V *
# # #
# # @ ) J
# # # #" )
" # # D@ # @ @ # E@ ) " , "# # # ) # )# # , # @
# ! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ A @ 5@ @ %- D''E # . @ @ 44 A #@ % D'&E " ,? 1 A 3 /O/> D>!7! 0 !") A 44@ '$E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+
44
+! , !
V .
A @ D'.E # " # : @ 1 B@ # ) @ *@ '*4 A @ D'.*E 9 # @ : " ! - @ 0 ,? + + DE@ * D *''*E + M >@ ; A @ D'''E
" "
# : # '@ '. ,? A DE@ 1 8 & " ( 0 + I 3 3 /OQ6RQS D>!7! A
A $.*@ ' *E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ A @ @ 5/ D'.&E + # # (# "
. , ( - . @ (@ A @ !# @ 2: D'.$E " ?
) # # @ @ $$ A @ @ @ +!@ %) @ A5@ % @ : :@ ! "@ %@ " @ ;! D''*E 9 " : " A" @ 5")8# '' ,? 7 1 %! A"" ) D E@ ! 2 - * 3 * D ''$4E A , " C # ) ! )@ K" ) > ) 0 A @ ! A @ A
@ 2+ D'''E / " :) @ '. ,? A DE@ 1 8 & " ( 0 + I 3 3 /OQ6RQS D>!7! A
A $.*@ .4 E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ K@ T@ T@ 0@ B @ 0@ @ Q@ B@ 3@ Q"@ 0 D'.E ; # # # #
) # # ,? * 0 , D &$. E ! #) -) "# / @ ;I %# @ /C -)@ 9 D'*$E -) # # " D #" E , 3 + +1+-+@ -@ $4 %# @ D''E -) # # - @ (@ ' ' % @ 2!@ > @ 5C@ + @ %+@ % "@ @ A : @ :3@ ! @ 5-7@ / @ @ : @ T D''*E ) : " A" ? , @
# @ @ # ) "# # ,? 7 1 %! A"" ) D E@ ! 2 - * 3 * D '.'4 E A , " C # ) ! )@ K" ) > ) 0 A @ ! !# @ 2: D'..E 3 , 3 & ! ( &1 ( ) , D>!7! A
A &+@ & E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !# @ 2: 7 @ 7 D'*.E ! , 3 1 2 3 3 D>!7! A
A :@ 4 E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !# @ 2:@ C#@ 50@ A @ A D''$E 3 , ) ! ( 3 D>!7! A
A $ &@ $* E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !# @ 2:@ 5@ %5@ "@ /7@ 7 @ /@ / @ ,@ , @ :@ ! @ :@ -)@ 2 D''*E " '' ## : " A" ,? 7 1 %!
!# .4W
*?/ 1
4
A"" ) D E@ ! 2 - * 3 * D '&'..E A , " C # ) ! )@ K" ) > ) 0 A @ ! !
@ 2 D'$4E - *GB3 B3 7 D>!7! ;" '*$+@ * E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !"@ +@ @ 0@ 9@ Q D'''E # # # ,? +0 5) @ 5- 3@ BT 0 D E@ , & 2 D 4 4'E ++ ; @ % ! @ ; %# @ /C D'**E ! ( , 1 D>!7! A
A 5@ * E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ ! @ ;@ %# @ /C@ -" @ 03 D'* E ! ( , 1 3 -F ! ! ( * D>!7! 0 !") A '.7@ * E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !@ 7+ 9 @ 05 D'.'E C ## "#
. @ (@ &$ &* !@ 7+ 3 @ % D''E 3 ? C # )
# ) # # # "" ,? %C 9 7+ ! D E@ I D!/A: !# A" # $@ $'&4E ! #)
! ) 7 )@ " @ 8 ! @ T2 D''&E 8 # # @ '(@ $4$4' @ 85@ / @ / D' 4E T %
1, - @ /"@ * * @ !A D'.'E ! @ ) ) # # ? A 9 @ !0 , # # @ '@ $ $ 4 %I@ 3 D'. E ! ) ,? * 6 0 , 3 //R/> 3 /OQ53 #C3 1 D . 'E 0 % " # /# # A A @ 1I@ C @ C+ D' *E " ) 1, - @ @ *&4 C @ C+ 1 # @ 71 D'*4E % #
1, - @ "@ 4&$ C @ 5 D'&.E ! )
# ,? %3 !#" @ %5 2 D E@ 2 1 D % # ; !# % &*@ E 1 +#) !## @ 0 @ 0
@ -- D'*&E ! ( - 1 * 1 - 0) I 3 1 D>!7! ;" ,@ & E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 0@ B D'.E , ! ( D! A 1 E , " -)
)# -) "# / @ ## > ) @ 3) )@ 0@ B D'.$E ; ) # # - @ @ '.&44 0@ B ! @ D'.&E J# ( # # # # " # # ,? 0% 0 DE@ ! , 2 * 66 1 D .4.$E , + # -) "# % #@ /# A )#S /O>= ! + * 62 ' ( D>!7! 0 !") A .**;@ .* E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 0@ :@ B@ T@ 3"@ 5@ "@ 0@ 0"@ 0 D'. E + ") " "# # # # ) # # ,? * 6 0 , 3 //R/> 3 /OQ53 #C3 1 D * *E 0 % " # /# # A A @ 1I@ 0@ Q K@ 1 D'.'E " "# # # # - @ "@ &..44 0@ B D''4E 3 # # " ,? %- 9 # DE@ * & 0 " 3 3 1 3 5KR 63 /OOK D *$*$*E + # ! #) / @ 1 T 0@ B 3 @ A D'' E " " "#" #) " - @ /@ $&&$'' 0 @ 2 D'.$E ) # # # ,? * 0 ! ( D $ .E , % # /
! @ ;I Q"@ 5 D'''E /
#" ) ) # # 3 A" 1 @ '@ ' Q"@ 5 D44E " #
) # # - * @ (@ & '&$. Q"@ 5 D44 E ,# " @ # @ " # # @ T % @ 1 @ -@ .' 4& Q"@ 5 D44 E -) # # T % "# ) # ? D . @ (@ ' 4 T@ 0 B @ 0 D'. E + ") # ) # #
" " ,? * 6 0 , 3 //R/> 3 /OQ53 #C3 1 D &$$E 0 % " # /# # A A @ 1I@ B@ - %@ B D'.E #" # ) # #
# 9 :@ "@ B " 0@ B@ K@ 9@ B@ A@ 7@ 9@ B D'. E # # "
# ) # # T % ,? * 6 0 , 3 //R/> 3 /OQ53 #C3 1 D *. *'E 0 % " # /# # A A @ 1I@
. & Jacques Locat and Homa J. Lee -?
;61F @6F;
!" !7! 89 % 4 * E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ + 2"" ++ ," "6KK5" & K5&S>5" @ +9@ / @ 03@ 2 @ D''&E 0, 0& N . " &' ( 3 3 1 D>!7! 89 % '&&&@ & E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ " )@ % 9I@ A D44E ># "# % - . @ "@ **' " #@ :@ : @ :5 D'.&E :
# # " ; " ? ! # " ,? 5/ 79 0# D E@ ! (", 2 * 3 D% / 7 )@ C &@ * .4E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8
@ 5 : )@ 5 D'''E %# "# # #)
3 % @ / A) @ ! . @ /DFE@ &''
@ +7 D'. E !18 /3 #R/Q D * .&E ( 7 @ A "@ ,)
@ 7; 9 @ A D44 E " ) # ) - @ DFE@ .'
@ :5 D'.'E 2 1 3 1 8 -, % "@ 3
@ :5 D''&E # # "? + " # ,? 5+ : @ ; " @ ; 9 @ ; 76 @ :: 0_ D E@ , 1 -, 2 * DC '@ $ E 7" 9 # C @ !"
@ :5 D'''E A # ? + #
" - * @ D'E@ .$.
@ :5 /) @ %5 D'.4E +
) ,? ## 7
" D E@ * 5 R# ( ? 1 . & 3 DC *@ &$E 1 B , " / @ 0
@ :5 7@ D'''E 9 R/Q D *&&E ++ ; @ % @ : ;"@ 5 D'''E : "" #) # #" . @ /DFE@ &$.& "@ % 56 @ ! D''$E 3 1 :# 7 ) ,? 9: :#7 + D E@ . 1 -, D $*.E 5 0) M ! @ # @ >2 /@ ! 0# @ 79 D E D'..E 3 ! 3 -F 5R=3 /OQ63 ! 3 1 D>!7! A
A @ 4 E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ / @ !7 "@ 55 D'' E %# ## # #
# #
# "
. @ /@ 4&. /) @ %5 D'&'E ! 0 )@ 1 B # ( ? @ DE@ & /) @ %5 /) @ 78 D'.E %# * // # ( ? . 1 3 D . E 1 B 7 # ! #)@ 0 /) @ %5@
@ :5@ 0 @ %- D'&.E 3 0 ) # ( ? . @ DE@ $.& 9@ 5@ 3"@ -@ 0"@ :5@ T"@ !2 D44 E # #
##"
# # '''
$*
V
7 " @ 5 D44E ##"
# ; ? D . 3 @ "@ - @ %/ D' .E A # #
" " # ) 0 @ 2 D44 E ! "
,? 22! - 2! 3 D E@ . - R !7! A
A $$@ @ &&E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 2 @ 2@ 0 @ %@ : @ %2@ ; @ //@ ;
@ 0: ,,,@ /@ !@ - @ /3@ 0# @ 79@ + @ !@ B @ %! D'.&E % " ) @ *@ ''$ 2 @ 2@ : )@ :/@ 9 #@ ! D44 E + .444) #
, " A " / 1G D $'&.E ++ ; @ % !#" @ %3@ 0# @ 79@ - @ 7@ ,, D''.E 3 ! " ")@ @ "
8# &@ '.'@ 3 A !7! A
A * 4@ $' E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ ! @ 5/ 3 @ %+ D''$E ! " ! " ? %
@ # @ " #" -, - . @ D E@ ' 4 ! @ 3 D'&'E
# " . * @ @ 4 ! @ 3 D''*E 7 #
A . 1 & @ BBB@ . ! @ 3 D''&E : " - #? + /"
# ,? 5+ : @ ; " @ ; 9 @ ; 76 @ :: 0_ D E@ , 1 -, 2 * DC @ .$ 44E 7" 9 # C @ !" ! @ 3 ! @ ! D44E J !7! A
A @ *E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 0# @ 79@ 3 @ /0@ /@ ! D'.'E ) # #
0 # 9
@ >@ '. '. - . & @ 'DE@ '4. 0# @ 79@ : @ ;+@ @ %- D444E ;" % # C -, - . @ 0DE@ 0# @ 79@ @ 5+@ 7 @ 50 D44 E "
,? %# @ 3 D E@ &' ( ) 2 3 * 3 2 * 5 0 & 1 3 , 3 () 3 /KR/6 D $&*.E : @ % 0 @ % D'.'E % @ " @ ? + # ,? A: ! : : D E@ & -, DA" # 1 @ 4&E , 7 # ! #)@ % @ + 0 @ % D444E # #) ,? A 9 !## D E@ * / * 1 3 3 0 3 /SR/>3 /OOO D $ E /"
7 ) # > / ; 0 @ % D44$E ) ! 9 # # ;) @ ,? 7@ : + @ :
D E@ ) D ' $ E 5 0) M ! @ 1 T 0 @ % 0# @ 79 D''$E % 3 - @ -, - . @ DE@ & 0 @ %@ @ 5@ /@ ! D''E , & ! ( 3 D>!7! 8( % '$@ $ E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+
*
V
0 @ %@ : @ %2@ ; @ 7/ D'' E 8 ) ! 9 # # ;) @ ,? -0 !@ ! !"@ 9 0 D E@ - D 4E ++ ; @ % B @ : - @ 0 D''E # # #) " ? + # ") ! + 1 3 +@ @ $'&
" 2 $
3 !! Susan H. Cannon and Joseph E. Gartner "?
;61F @6F;
0 ( #
" J# )
# " # # ) "J@ ) @ # " # @ # # # ( # # #
) @ # ( @ "
# " ( @ # " # ) ##" @ 6G
1"
" " #" # ##"
# ( D@ A
@ '.&S : @ '.'S :) 0 @ ''&S @ 44 E - @ ") '$ #) " @ D44E " # )
"# S ) " 4X #
&
2 $ 3 !!
V $
@
# "
"# " # #@ #@ # ) # " # ) #(#) #) ( , # # #
"# ( @ # #
"# ""
# # #"
# )@ " (# @ @ @ " )@ 8 # ) # ) J# ##"
#
" S # ( J# # ) # #
) # ) "??
> 9
; " )
# ) )
"# ( : &4X *4
" " J " #
#" 7 D44 E " ) # )
# ) @ )
7 D44 E " # ) @ D44 E " # "
"
#) " # " ) ? % & 4$$ . *0
$
% # D F E@ D #E@ " D E@ 0 ) D F E I" 4*& + " " )
" "@ " D @ 44 E
"?"
.@##1G ; F; @.F;.
#
"
# (
" " >!+ # ! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ @ 5@ %"@ 5@ + @ / D44 E 9
) @ D5" ) @ 44 @ ;E @ 7; D'& E 9 " @ ; !" 1 . @ '@ & $ @ 5+@ 7 @ 50@ A @ :@ : # @ + D44 E /
) " )@ # # @ )@ , &4 ) #
@ # @ >!+ ,? %# 3 D E@ * 5 0 1 &' ( ) 2 3 * 3 3 /KR/63 , 3 () D 4.$ 4'*E : @ % @ :@ A @ 3@ : @ A@ 9 @ 9@ %# @ @ %@ 3 D44 E !+ 9 ! # % # A ,1 &@ E >!
+ #"" @ 0 @ -# @ 5 D'*$E . I 3 I I3 D>!7! A
A . E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ -)@ 5+ D'.4E /J# # 0 ( " J
"# @ '@ *&* , "" "@ /7@ @ % @ A# @ % @ 3"#@ - D44 E + # " ) @ -@ 4 5 @ +: D'. E # " ) 5% % ,? ; " ; A D E@ 0 D $& *E 5 0) M ! @ 1 T 2 # @ 78 -)@ 5 D'&*E ( 1 0 * 5 ! 0 & 1 3 66R6=3 , 3 1 D ''.E 0 % " # "#@ @ 8 3 @ ,5 D44 E 9
? ) 7 % ) " 1 : "@ > D'* E :!# @ > ! > )@ 3 @ > 3 @ : ! @ + D'' E + )" "
#
@ A" %# . 4 @ ("@ 3)@ 5 D44E " # !+ * @ "@ '.'' :
)@ 5+ : @ + D44 E , )
# # ( 9
% - * @ '@ 4 '4&4 : @ : D'.'E " ! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ A
@ @ @ !-@ A #@ 23 D44 E 4 & ! ! ( 6KK/ D>!7! 0 % " # , % 4 'E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ %"@ !3 #@ 0/ D'.&E # " ? /
: ") ,? 5/ 79 0# D E@ ! (" , 2 * 3 3 D% / 7 ) 1 C,,@ *$.4E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8 ! @ A 5"@ 5@ - @ ; D44E ! * 0 3 -& 1 3 1 D+ # A
1 @ 'E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8 !#@ 2:@ % @ 55@ ! # @ 5@ #@ 0/@ : )@ % !#" @ D44E )
# "# " # ) 8 % 1 . @ *@ ''$4 !# @ 2: D'&E /O>O ! ( . 3 1 D>!7! A
A &$4@ &E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !# @ 2: 0 @ %A D'&.E - $ , 3 1 D>!7! A
A 4 4E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ ! )@ %+@
@ !-@ 0 @ %A D444E
# )
#)? "
"" # # @ J @ &.' !" @ ! D44E 3 ( ? +
; 1 9 :!# @ ; ! > )@ , ! @ / D''$E 9 ,? 5/ 2) !# D E@ 4 1 2 - D 4E , + # 0 9 @ 9 (@ 0+
!# $*W
"?' 1
.$
! @ 95 D'.E 9 #
# ,? -+ :
)@ - ; @ 13 @ 5/ 3 @ 0+ % D E@ ! - * D>!+ 9 ! # 7 ## % 08*@ 4 4E >!
+ #"" @ 0 @ ! @ 1 D'&$E * ( , & A D>!+ 9 ! # 7 ## % A10@ E >! + #"" @ 0 @ ##@ ; @ 7% D''&E ) # " ,? 3 DE@ &' ( ) 2 3 * 3 2 * / 0 1 3 ! 3 1 3 @RO D $ E + # ! #) / @ 1 T ##@ @ ; @ 7%@ : @ -/ D444E # " # " ,? 79 0# 1 1 D E@ &' ( ) 2 3 * 3 D .''&E ++ ; @ % 0 @ 07@ ,, D'.E ! J# " (
# # ! " - *4 3 13 # ( ? DC @ 4$ E , + # -)
# !## @ #" #@ 1 B 0 @ 07@ ,, D'.&E J# ( " ,? 5/ 79 0# D E@ ! (", 2 * 3 3 D% / 7 ) 1 C,,@ 4$ E 0 @ // A @ AA D''E # -"#"# : " " + . @ @ & ' 0 @ !: 2@ 57 D44 E A (
# A#(# 1 % # ) : " % ! - @ (*@ &$.& B @ %% D'.E ! D,+-! 1 @ $&E , + # -)
# !## @ #" #@ 1 B
'
Roy C. Sidle '? '??
;61F @6F; )
# " #
- @ @ "@ # ) ## D@ 5 @ 444S !@ 444S 7" @ 44E 0 # !+ 9 ! # % # A ,1 '4@ & E >! + #"" @ , " 9 % / ! @ 8@ >
4
V *
;"
" @ /%@ @ 7%@ @ :+ D'&*E 1 & D4 E ;" " 3 :@ A @ 8% @ 1 D'.4E % )" #
. 4 @ '@ & @ !- %"@ !3 D444E ( @ " ) @ 1 :# - * @ "@ 4 @ @ 3@ @ @ T; D444E 9" "" " # ''' D .&'*E % # 3 )@
@ >2 ,@ D'' E +
) " . A @ @ & V 5 W , @ 53 D'.$E :" )@ 9 @ 8 : )@ % ;"L @ 5: D''&E # ) " . @ /-@ $'** :
@ A- D'&$E /# # # # ) ; " @ C# " 8=3 "@ 3 A #@ +5 D'&*E , "# # ) ) @ 1 0 @ 1 B 0 - . @ @ * 8@ T D''E , "# ##) )
# # # # @
# @ ? D . 3 #+!+ @ '@ *$&. A# @ @ 7 #ZP @ %@ %" @ C@ C@ % D44 E # ? !
7 @ ! 1 @ "@ $ 4 A @ 5 0 @ +5 D'' E # ( ? 2 , ( D3# % # !## ! 1 &@ & E 3# @ 3# @ 1 B A
@ ,A 0 @ 3 D''.E J# ( " J
/"#)" * @ @ $*$ %@ + 1) @ % D'.E + !#? : ) ) # ) . 4 @ '@ . '* %@ + 1) @ % D'..E : @
# ## "#" !# " # . 4 @ @ $$ %"@ !3 #@ 0/ D''E /
" 8 %? /# RQ ! /OQS D>!+ 9 ! # 7 ## % A10.4@ $4E >! + #"" @ A#(# 1 9 % / ! @ A @ 8% ! @ / D'. E + " # )
# # #) * -F ! A - D ''4&E / 0 @ - ""@ -, ! @ /@ 5 " @ @ @ ! D'.'E A #) ! " D, )
# # E # . A @ /@ *&. V 5 W !@ % D'.4E 0 ! * - D>!+ / A" # 1 A10'$@ $ E >! + #"" @ A#(# 1 9 % / ! @ @ 8% !@ % D'. E !
" "#" " # + ? . . ) @ /@ &''$ !@ % D''E + # #" #
# -, % @ /@ $ !@ % D''E + # J# ) @ *@ .'&'4 !@ % D444E 0 # " )? + # " "
* ( 6/ 1 2 1 D>!+ 9 ! # A
# %:%!A @ $$*E >! + #"" @ % # ) : " % # ! @ 9 @ 8
4.
V *
!@ % @ : D44 E 3 2)" "@ 5 - 3 . A @ *"D$E@ $$ !@ % @ +! D44E A J#
#
,? % ! DE@ -, 1 . ) ! D, > 9 ) % # 8 % # ! 1 '@ *$E +; , A @ 8 @ >2 !@ % 0"@ 0 D'''E !" J# " ? D . 3 #+!+ +@ @ .$4 !@ %@ A #@ +5@ 8=3 "@ 3 D'.$E A D0
% " # : C @ 4 E + # 7 ) # > @ 0 @ !@ %@ ) @ @ 3"@ QQ@ + @ 01@ 3 @ 5@ 3@ 0A@ 1@ %1@ @ 5% D44 E , # " " ? /# # # # % 0 @ *J-@ .4 ! " @ +@ !@ !@ : @ 2 D''*E J#
# @ # "# @
8 # 9 " ) ''* * *4 # ( ! ! /OO> 0 1 3 @RQ3 * 3 D 44*E + # , " -)
)@ ! A"@ :1 !)@ A+ B @ D E D''&E ! * D0 % ## #" 1 '@ 0 % A
E ; " : ) /
@ C# " !)@ 7 % )@ !+ D444E > ? ,## #" # 1
P@ % 5
!@ ; . @ /@ '$& ! @ 9 D'..E +
)= # 1 , @ @ $&$. ! @ 95 ! @ 1 D'&&E 1 7 , 1 3 D% / 7 ) C @ 3 @ E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8 ! @ 95@ 9 @ %3@ :# @ 9: D'.E : 8 ,? %3 / DE@ 1 ! - & A D **E -"# % @ !
" " @ A+ ! @ 95@ 2 @ 2@ @ 1@ 0
@ %7 D'..E 3 J# # )
# @ *@ ''. ! @ 1 ! @ 95 D'&*E @
@ ) A#(# 1 ,? % DE@ . - D ''E @ -"# M % @ !
" " @ A+ " @ C D''*E ) 1 0 D$ E , , : " @ 2"@ 1 @ %; :@ 09 D''.E A # #"
@ # @ 8 ? + # @ @ ' 4
@ + 2@ %: D'.$E J# 9
@ 4 ) @ @ '$' " "@ 1+ % @ % D'..E ! @ @ 1 B . @ @ *4
!# **W
'?' 1
4'
" "@ 1+@ 3 @ :7@ @ C5 D'. E #
# " ) "
"# 1 B * 6 0 1 - 1 , 3 A, (3 + @ 9 D'.$E
! " 1 . @ @ *. !I@ - D''*E " 6 "6
; "" 0 V 7 W 2@ 0 D'. E C C "" " ;")# "? 0 # "" > "# & ( , @ . 5 @ ! @ *'. V 7 W 2@ 0 D''.E C 7 " C "" ) & ( , &
@ * 5 @ '@ ' V 7 W 2 @ - D44 E / ) ) " ,? 5 B #" + 2" D E@ - # 2 5 0 & 0# 1 - # + * 3 /OOQ D $$$$* E ! C @ ; 2 @ 3 D''.E +" " % " ! & ( , @ '@ 4& V 7 W 2
2 " @ 7 D'&4E > J 0 #
, & @ **@ &&& V 7 W 3) @ / D'*$E ; " 0 !
" + " & ( , @ @ $ . V 7 W 3) @ / D'*$ E 0 :" & ( , @ @ '$* V 7 W 3) @ / D'*$#E !# " / # +" "
7 # " # & ( , @ @ $&*$ V 7 W 3) @ / D'*&E %# " ; " 0 # "" " %" " 7 # & ( , @ @ $ V 7 W 3) @ / D'&E / " 9 " " >
5 '*$ ; , " 3#
;;0 , @ (# # # $ # " '''
@ "
"# # #" "
##"
# , ## # "# # @ ( #
# ) ) )
##" # /?-
.616)C). DF1 #6C6F;
: " ) 1C,!,!@ # ! @ 55 D'$&E , , ##@ 1 T 0# @ 79@ 3 @ :@ / @ 3!@ : @ ;+@ ; @ 53 D44E &' ( ! ) 1 /OOO 1 I ) D>!7! 89 % 4 E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 0 @ :7 D'$ E + # - 3 . A @ "D*E@ # @ '$'$* B @ 8@ 9 P@ :@ A@ 7@ 2 #@ ! D'' E * ) - ) D% 5 (E / #" A P## 1# @ K"
6! + 6
Chyan-Deng Jan and Cheng-Lung Chen
?
;61F @6F;
+ " ##"
''* )
- ) ) )
) # # / ")@ # ##" " * # ) " " ) D # E # # @ # # "# ## " @
" ##@ " ## # # # ##" " D
# E
" @ ") @ # ( ## +) " D
# E # @ # ##"
#
? 6! + $ $
!# W
Rainfall intensity (mm/hr)
Rainfall record at Alishan
Duration of rainfall (hr)
Hourly rainfall (mm)
D ?"? % )" )
- + ! 9 # @ #
" "
Time (hr)
D ?'? - " ) " " ) " " )
- " " ) + Q " " # 44
6! + 6
V
Hourly rainfall (mm)
$ *
July, 1996
August, 1996
D ?(? - " ) )
+ ! " )
7 -
+ @ " ) " 44$F @
# # # , " ) D # E # 44$F @ )
##"
D # E # 8 # )@ " 44$F @ ##"
@ " @ 44$F @ # " ) # " (##
# ) 9
@ ") & 4$.F @ # " $ " D44$F E
D " $ E@ ##"
# ") & , @ "
" $44 @444 4F @ # " 44$F + "
)
" $44@444 @ $ ") & + J#
##"
#@ # #" " ) #" " #
J "#
44$F "
? 6! + $ &
!# W
6 ?? ! # # & @ # #" ) )
- ) " + D''.E "
# DE "
+ #( D E 1" 1" F
7
" DE
+ #( D E -) ) DX E 1" 1" F
7") D E
+ #( D E 1" 1" F
$4 $444
4444
44 44
44 44
1+ . 1
1+ . 1
1+ * 1
1+ 1
1+ 1
44$44 1+
$44
1
1+ $ 1
$44
$44@444
@444@$44
@$44
' 44&*
.'. 44 ' 4
. * 4
$ $ 44 &
'$ 44 & 44$
*
*
&
&
&
&
.* 4 4
$ 4*4
. 4$.
$ $ 4'
*& * 44.'
&4 44
'$ & 44$
%
" ##
1,-)
8
1
+ #( # D E 1" 1" F
1+ & 1
1+ 1
1+ . 1
3 # ( ##
%"
1
/ \
1
+ #( # D E 1" 1" F
& 4$
*& $ 44&$
' * 4
& * 44'
'$ & 44$
3 " ##
1"
9 4X #""
9 4X #""
+ #( # D E 1" 1" F
1+ 1
1+ ' 1
1+ $ 1
T
1
) #H 1"
DE
*44
*44.44
.44@444
@444@44
@44
+ #( D E 1" 1" F
4 4 ,1
$4 . 4$'
4$& . 44'
$ * 44
' $ 4.
'$ & 44$
1+ 1 1 ) ##" " " ) #(
# 8 ) 1 > ) D1 >E ,1 ,
$ .
6! + 6
V
@ # ) ) )
) ##"
# , # @ ) ) J# # @ # @ ##"
#@ " "
, ## # @ @ ) "# #" J# ) 8+@ 44 " " # "# #" ## # = #)
) #"
" ?'
F; @.F;.
# )@ #"@ V W
!# .W
?* 1
$*
@ 5@ 0"@ -3@ @ 35 D''&E + #
,? 3 DE@ * / 0 1 &' ( ) 2 3 * 3 3 ! 3 1 D ' 4E + # ! #) / @ 1 T @ 5@ !"@ %%@ 0"@ -3 D444E -)
# # # "
" ,? 79 0# 1 1 D E@ * 6 0 1 &' ( ) 2 3 * 3 3 3 ( D $. $'E ++ ; @ % @ 5@ T@ 53@ @ T-@ 0"@ -3@ - @ D44 E 3 "# ) )
I@ 5") ' 4@ 44 # ,? %# 3 D E@ * 5 0 1 &' ( ) 2 3 * 3 3 , 3 () D ''''E : @ % @ !- D''*E % # )
- # * - -, 3 3 ( D &E 1 > )@ @ V W @ A0 D # E D''&E , ( & ) 0
D$ E ! 0 ;" "@ 9 ) ;" " + #"" 9 ) A
#@ V W @ A0 D # E D''.E ) 1
D' E "# + #"" @ @ 0 ! + # @ @ V W "@ T D''&E ,
" #" ) )
- * / # ! ( 1 3 T 3 ( D $ E 1 " - > )@ @ V W @ !5@ - " @ 1@ @ -@ @ 0;@ - @ :3@ !@ !@ -"@ 5@ - @ :5@ @ :@ ! @ A@ 3"@ @ 3@ 5 D44 E 3
@
" J ) #)
# @ '@ * .*$ @ 1% !@ - D'.E 5 0) M ! @ 1 T 9@ 5@ 3"@ -@ 0"@ :9@ T"@ !2 D44 E # #
##"
# # ''' )@ #"@ V W 3@ !@ @ T2@ 3 "@ 5 D'''E ! ) # #" ) )
- ) 1 1 , @ /D E@ V W 3@ :3@ "@ :-@ -"@ 9/@ 3"@ T-@ @ 0 @ -"@ 7 @ 3@ -- D444E .0 1 &' ( , 1 D1 !## # ) A
- : ''' +" % @ $ E 1 !## "#@ @ V W 3@ :3 5@ 9! D444E # # "# ) ) ) ? )
- - . @ "*@ '4& 3@ :3@ 5@ 9!@ 0"@ D''*E @ # @ #
) &. @ "(@ V W 3@ !0 D''.E % )
- ''* @ DE@ .44 V W 3"@ 29@ !@ 3@ - @ 0 D''.E 0 * C &' ( ) & 0 D% @ E 1 !## "#@ @ V W ! @ 0 D' E 9 @ 7 )@ 1 > )@ @ "# + #"" @ @ V W @ 25@ !"@ T:@ 0@ -T@ 3@ 5; D''*E 7,!F7A! # )
#" ) )
- @ # #
) &. @ "(@ $$* V W 0@ ! D''E 0 1 D% E 1 !## "#@ @ V W
!# .W
?* 1
$*
0@ 01@ T@ T@ @ @ 3@ : D444E # # " "# ) ' !7! 8( % .E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ K@ 1 0@ B- D''4E N + !## A @ ;I V W !# @ 2: D'.'E 3 , & ! ( 1 ( ) , 3 + + D>!7! A" # AA+'E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ @ D'''E :## # " ,? 1R 1 I ! ( D '$E , " : " - M /
@ +!@ A % # , "@ 2) > ) @ ;Q@ B "@ ;9@ 0"@ 5! D444E ! ( 1 D 4E # A @ ;I V W 0@ TT@ 5@ @ -@ 03@ - @ T@ B "@ %T D44 E !
# " #) 1 . ) 1 @ DE@ ' V W 0@ TT@ 5@ @ -@ 03@ B "@ %T D44 E + ") # "#" ##"" " #@
" "#" # " ) # # @ DE@ 4$4 V W 0@ TT@ 5@ @ T@ ;T D44E ! ( -" !## # ) A @ @ V W 0@ 05@ B@ !@ 0@ 5T D'. E 1 . ! ( .7 . 3 D: 3 " , " 7# ) M ) )@ . E +#) !##@ ;I@ !## A @ ;I V W 0@ 9K@ -"@ 2-@ "@ A@ @ 5@ -@ TA D44E :# # Q I % ) 5I " 7") 1 ,& @ 'D*E@ &&$ V W
$'
7 8 1 $
V
0"@ 5!@ 2@ B@ @ 3K@ B@ ! D''4E ! ( , C , 3 $ !## A @ ;I V W 0"@ 5!@ @ 3K@ 2@ B@ B@ !@ 3"@ 5 D'' E ! ( 0 1 , 1 !## A @ ;I V W T@ 2 D44E % # 5I " 7") :!# @ +#) !## V W T@ B1 D'. E I ! ( * - * D: 3 " , " 7# ) M ) )@ $E +#) !##@ ;I@ !## A @ ;I V W B@ ! D44 E # " " ,? %# 3 D E@ &' ( ) 2 3 * & 3 + : @ % B@ Q; 3"@ 5 D'.'E ! ( C 3 $ * , D 4 4 E " ) A @ "@ V W B@ Q; 3"@ 5 D'.'E ! ( C 3 $ * , D 4 4&E " ) A @ "@ V W
& . Terrence P. Rollerson, Thomas H. Millard, and Denis A. Collins ?
;61F @6F;
) ! 7 # !" )@ # "@ 44 E # # # 3 % # #
"#
(?"?
6A
" : " ! - ) )@ " ) # # ) # #
# S # )
&4.
# .? += 2 = @.
V &
" # ) # ( #S
# ) ; # # ) D" (E@
) @ #
#
A #
"
# )#) "
" ) " @ " #) ) ) # # # #@ #) # )#) #
# @ ) # " @ )
#" "
" ) # "
" " @ #" )
# C # "
) " 7 # D E # @ @ , # ) # S # D9" &E 7 ) ) " @
) D" # E D" # E D9" &D;@@/EE , # @ # ) ) @ " # @ ) D@ !# @ '..E , # @ # )#) " " ) "
" " # , '.4 @ # " $4 # # ) @ " " , @ # # # ) ##""
"# @ # DA @ '.$E@ #
D!# @ '..S 9" &E , # " # ##"" " D9" &E 3# # : " ! - # # " # :) # # " # # # # D9" &D+/EE # (#)
) ) # @
# #
, # @ # # )
"
" # @ ) # # # # # D9" &D9ES :I !# @ '..S !# @ '..@ @ '.'E # ""
# ; # # " : " ! - ) !" # " ) "# # ) # "
)
" D@ A @ '.$S :I C @ '.*S 0@ '.'E !" # " )
# # ( #
S '.4 " " # # @ # #)
!# &$W
(?" !
&4'
D (?? )# " : " ! - D+E : @
) "
# " # D;E :" # "# 1 ! " 9 " % @ $4
# 1 @ @ > ( # # #
) # # + " $ # DE : @
) '.4 ) " 4 # # : " # " $ DE '.4 A # # ) 1
# D/E '.4 # # ) D9E # " % ) # "
" # ! " 3 DE@ DE@ D/E # '.4
#@ )
D@ 9 @ '.S A @ '.$S :I
C @ '.*S !# @ '..S :I !# @ '..E + # @ @ '.4 " ) #) "# "" D!# @ '..E # @ ) @ # D!# @ '..E ) @ ) "1. D F2.
! " :") % ) ) '.4 #" (# # (# ) 0 #
" 1 9 " )@
" ) # ) #@
@ #
@
^ ) #
) ( # @ ##)@ ( "#" @ "#
" , # # #
# 5 D'.E 3 D'.E + % @ 1 9 " ) # ( ) # . # ) " $ # #) "# # # )# ##) " #
% % # D9" &E " @$4 F + @ #
"# " 4X " " D3 @ '.E 1 9 " " " % @ #)
# ) " . # "# % ) " # I" ) " #@ " ) # #)# # @ @ # " ! 7 # !" )@ # "@ 44 E ##) # " @ #" @ #" >!U D9 ) -@ '.E + " )@ 1 9 " ! " 9 "
) ) " 44 @
) ) @ " " 44 )
@ ) " # @
) ) " #) ") ) , $ ) ;" 1 ) #
" %
# "# % @ A !@ " ) ) )
" !7! D;E A ? ; 5 @ >! + ) /
&4
# .? += 2 = @.
V &
" L# " " # # " " # " 1 '.4 " # #" # ) " >!U$ A C# " D9 ) -@ '.E ;) 8# '.@ 8/ " . "
" % 9
:) '.4 8# '.@ 8/ ) &&
"@ @ " % D!#" @ '. E + A :") % ) @ '.4 @ # "
) * >! 9 ! #
! % @ " # A " @ A#(# A 3 ## $ " @ ) " @ "# RR == " (# #
"# ##) #) ; '.4 ''4@ >!U
#" ) '.4 @ # #@ " " " # # @ # "# "#" 1 9 " ) D9" & &.E@ # "#
# "
" ! 3 @ ) " " " " # " # (?*
D1)H@);G ; #C;6@ ) FD 1C) )>1. D F2.
3 : " ! - ##" !7! #" .$4@ E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+
@ 2+ A @ A D''4E +# ' :) '.*@ : " ! - @ 0 # ( @ ' @ $'*
# 1"PG@ 7@ C#@ 50@ % @ 0, D'' E + " " #"#
P # @ :# ? ,# I . @ "-@ $ * @ % D'.&E * &/OQK * ! ( + I 3 D>!7! A
A @ ' E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ @ %@ :""@ %@ %" @ : D'&$E : " ! - # ? # "" @ *(@ . " @ 5 D'.E ' ( /Q3 /OQK3 - + 3 D>!7! #" .$4;@ * E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ @ %3 D'''E * /O3 /OQ6 D>!7! A
A $.*@ &$E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ "@ 9 #@ 3- D'. E /
" : " ! - @ 'D E@ @ 'D$E@ "@ 3 @ 3; D'.E ! ) 1 ( ) , + - D% @ &4 E 9 / #) : +#)@ % 4@ !@ 0+ / @ %@ )@ :+@ 9# @ %5@ 3 @ :+@ @ + @ ! 0 I## @ +: D44 E ) 0 ! 9 #@ 3- D'.&E #
# . , ( - . @ (@ $* 9 #@ 3- 0 @ : D'. E )# " # # # # . :) '.4 " % @ 0 * - 1 I D ## : " '4.@ $ E A" # 0 % # , "@ " " @ 5 9 @ 5-@ :@ :@ =+@ %/@ 7 )@ % D'.E % #
" # ! '.4 " : " ! - # @ 0 . @ *@ * 9 @ %3 D'. E * D. E -@ +" @ Q 9 )@ ;3@ -@ : D'.E I - /OQK + 2 ! /KK D>!7! A
A '@ $ E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 7 @ 73 A @ D'.$E * 1 ! ( 8 & ! /OQK3 - ! , 3 D>!7! 0 !") A & @ E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 7 )@ 2/ D'. E ! ) 1 9 ! " 9 " " " '.4 " : " ! - D$ E :!# @ > )
! ; 7# @ - D''*E & , /Q3 /OQK3 + I 3 D>!7! 8( % '**&&@ '4 E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 7# @ - D''.E % # # :) .@ '.4@ : " ! - # @ 0 . , @ -@ $$4* - @ 5- D444E A # I" @ :") % @ : " ! - @ 0 D' E :!# @ ! > )@ 9 -" # @ ;A ! @ + D''4E %# # # : " ! - # @ 0 . 1 @ (@ $ - @ %A@ : @ @ C#@ 50 D'.E * /Q D>!7! A
A $4@ 4 4E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ -)@ 5- D'&$E A * * &' ( 3 + I 3 D>!7! ;" . ;@ 4 E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ -)@ 5-@ @ % D'&.E * I 3 * ) ! - D>!7! A
A
4@ & E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ , @ %:@ %@ :/@ 3-" @ %7 D''&E
, ( - * @ "@ .$ . , @ %:@ !#@ !A@ C#@ 50 D''.E 8 I#
# . @ /@ '&'. 5@ %5@ !# @ 2:@ 1 @ 2:@ : @ -+ D'.E , 3 -F 3 D>!7! A
A $4@ * &.E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 5@ %5@ :) @ 9@ @ D'. E ! # # " '.4'. " : " ! - @ 0 @ (DE@ 4@ (D E@ $'
!# &W
(? 1
&&
5 : ) "# D''E - + ! & A) I * C D 4 E !
@ 5 : ) "# @ ) 5 : ) "# D''$E ! ( C DC @ . E 8 " 0 8L#@ 2)" " % "# ;" "@ 5 : ) "# @ A" # 0 % # , "@ " " 5 @ +: D'&4E * * . D$&& E 9 @
@ M @ ! 9 # # 3-" @ %7 D''*E ! ( A . I D>!7! 9# ! *'*E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 3@ 9@ " @ 5@ C @ ;@ !"@ -@ !" ) @ + D444E 3 : # @ 5 I . @ //@ $* 3 @ +2@ @ ;@ "@ D'. E A " " 1 9 " % @ 5" '.45" '. ? D . @ + @ '@ *$ 3@ A0 :""@ % D E D'.E /OQK - + 3 D>!7! A
A $4@ . E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 3 @ %/@ : @ :;@ 1 @ 3:@ 2 @ 3@ @ A5 D'.E 0 ' ( /Q ( 1 ( ) , D>!7! A
A $4@ *' *''E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 3 @ 5%; D44E ) 3 :" * 08 @ 5" :I @ 55 D'. E 7 # # # # # :) .@ '.4 " : " ! - @ 0 :!# @ A ) ! > )@ ! :I @ 55 D''&E
# # . @ /"@ $ ** :I @ 55 D444E 7 ) # " "
? ,# # # # @ (/@ * . :I @ 55 D44 E A " )
) ## ) 0*1@ "@ 4$ :I @ 55 D44 E A " " : " ! - ? # # # I" # . & @ /-@ 9444@ ?44'F445944444 :I @ 55 1@ 7 D'.'E ! # " " # ## "
I @ "@ & :I @ 55 C @ ; D'.*E ! ) # . :) '.4 " @ : " ! - @ 0 * @ "'@ *'&4$ :I @ 55 !# @ 2: D'..E I ( , I 3 + 3 2 * 3 -7 3 ) D>!7! ;" . @ . E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ :I @ 55@ A @ @ @ %3@ @ 5/ D444E ! ) ## " # + # #
: " ! - . @ *@ .'. :I @ 55@ !#@ !A@ A" @ %@ / # @ D44 E &' ( ) , 3 I 3 I 3 - , D7!+ !# A
&$@ .'4.E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8
&.
# .? += 2 = @.
V &
:#7" @ 05 D''*E I 0 2 , ( 1 D!# A" # 4@ E 7 # ! #) 3 : @ %+@ 0@ %;@ ! @ + D'..E 7 )
# # " )
# #
: " ! - # @ >!+ I @ "/@ $ :) @ 9 5@ %5 D'.*E !
. :) '.4 1 9 " % # @ : " ! - @ 0 ,? !+ 2 DE@ + 2 !, $ D *..*E / 0 > ) A @ ) :) @ 9 : @ -+ D'.'E %
# #
# ) '.4 " : " ! - @ 0 @ @ $& :) @ 0@ ! @ :+@ 7# @ -Q@ C @ ; D'.$E -F . 3 3 ) ! 1 1
+ 3 D>!7! A
A $@ E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ : @ @ :""@ %@ @ % D'.E ) + D>!7! A
A $4@ &.'.4E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ :""@ % @ % D'*E %#
: " ! - @ 0 . @ (@ .$$.&4 :""@ %@ @ % D'.E - , + D>!7! A
A $4@ $E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 1@ 7 D'.E + # #
: " ! - - 3 & . A @ 'D $E@ 1@ 7 A" )@ %! D E D''*E ! 2 - * 3 * D* E > ) 0 A @ ! 8= @ 5/@ - @ 5-@ @ 5/ D44E ! ( ! # & F 3 D>!7! A
A *4*@ ' E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ A @ D'.$E , '.4 A :") %
@ : " ! - @ 0 . @ -'@ 4$* 4*' A @ D'.*E 9 # @ : " ! - @ 0 ,? + + DE@ * D *''*E + M >@ ; A @ D'''E ! ! ( ! ( - & & 1 /O3 /OQ6 D>!7! A
A $.*@ ' *E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ A @ D44 E % " # A#(#% # * . * 1 # &% 1 I 3 /6R/=3 * 3 7 D *E > 1# +" P :P# @ :# ) A @ 5@ %5 D'' E C ## # ? + # "
# # # . @ /'@ $ $. A @ !# @ 2: D'.$E "
) # # @ @ $$
!# &W
(? 1
&'
A @ 0@ %; D'''E & &( ! ( . -7 , - ! 6R53 /OQ5 D>!7! A
A $.*@ $ *.E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ A @ @ 5@ %5@ " @ 5@ ;
@ + D''4E A "
# ) 1 '.$ " 1 %"@ @ # !7! 0 % " # , % ' 4&$@ .4 E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !#" @ %3 D'. E / # '.4 : " ! - " - . @ /@ $ !# @ 2: D'.$E 3 : " ! - @ 0 @ >!+ * 0 - 3 ! (3 * , 3 5R=3 3 D 4' E /
/ ! #) 5@ ) !# @ 2: D'..E 3 , 3 & ! ( &1 ( ) , D>!7! A
A &+@ &. E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !# @ 2: D'.. E 3 , 3 * 1 + 3 D7!+ !# A '@ *E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8 !# @ 2: D'.'E ! 8 & ! ( & 1 ( ) , D>!7! A
A &;@ E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !# @ 2: D44 E 3 @ @ # #" @ @ ) : " % @ 0 * . * 1 # R% 1 I 3 /6R/=3 * 3 7 D &E > 1# +" P :P# @ :# ) !# @ 2: "# @ ! D44 E ! " : " ; @ 1 # + . ,# # . ( * @ D&E@ !# @ 2:@ C#@ 50@ A @ A D''$E 3 , 3 ) ! ( 3 D>!7! A
A $ &@ $* E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !# @ 2:@ :#ZP @ 53@ 1 I @ 5+@ % ZP "@ !@ :#7@ 5A D44E 1& ! ( I 2 3 ) 3 D>!7! A
A * 4@ $' E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !# @ 2:@ C#@ 50@ 2 @ 1@ :#ZP @ 53@ ! "#@ 0@ @ 7 D E
# # C # @ 1# "? 8##"
#@ " @ - * +
& 4
# .? += 2 = @.
V &
! @ 3 D'. E 3 ## # ? # # " # @ @ # " I . @ @ * '& ! @ 3@ 2 )@ A@ A" @ % D44 E I C , I 3 - , 3 1 ( 1 - 4 & -, D7!+ !# A &$@ $ E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8 ! @ ! @ 3 D'' E I D ' E 7 ## A @ "# @ +B ! @ + D'''E 1 & , /OQK - + 3 D>!7! 8( % '** @ 4 E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ !@ 7+@ 9 @ 05 D'.'E C ## "#
. @ (@ &$ &* ! , " D'' E %I # . I # ( @ -D4E ! , " D''*E 3 : # . I # ( @ D'E " @ 5@ + " #@ 2/@ ; " @ 53@ ;
@ ! D''.E 8 @ # # # @ " ''4 " 2" # @ 5 D, E I @ "-@ *4 .4 @ %, D444E : " ! - 4 ) ? 0 = . @ "@ ' >! + ) / D44E + - D #" 9 % @ E >! + ) / @ A #@ A @ 8% C#@ 50 D'.$E 3 A # -
% @ 8% - 3 & . A @ ''D *E@ $4 C#@ 50 D'''E * * ) , ( ! 3 D>!7! ;" *@ ' E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ C#@ 50 D444E 3 ,? - !" @ ; - " @ !% :#1"@ - %) @ 5 ! D E@ - I D *4**E +## A @ ! C#@ 50 !# @ 2: D''&E 8 # "
: " % ? ! ) # " #) # . @ /-@ * C @ ; D'.E ! /Q - D>!7! A
A $4@ *'.*E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ C @ ;@ 7# @ -@ 5@ %5@ " @ A: D'.E 1 , /Q D>!7! A
A $4@ & &&E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 0@ %; D'.E , * ! ( ! /Q2 D>!7! A
A $4@ ' *4E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ 0@ %; D'.'E !
D E #" ) )
# # " : " ! - # @ 0 @ . :) '.4 I @ "@ .$& 0@ %; :#3 @ 1! D'.&E : " : " ! - #) # # : #+ '. , . - @ ((@ $$ &'
!# &W
(? 1
&
0@ %;@ A @ @ :#3 @ 1!@ 5@ %5@ C @ ;@ - # @ % D'. E / " #@
@ : " ! - ? /J#
# @ @ ' '& 0 @ 5! @ 3 D''$E 9 !7! 8( % '$ '&@ E >! 7 # !" )@ % @ C+ B " @ A-@ + @ ;9@ C#@ 50@ ; @ -@ ;
@ + D44 E - # )
"# # 0 %
: " % ! ,? 0 ! DE@ 1 C D9 7" @ 4' E 7 # ! #) + #@ ; " @ 8
A
##
'* +# " # 9 : D+9:E '*@ $' # D( E * # " J . && ) $. # "#" && $
#
$. $4 . "#" $
) && J .
)@ "#
'' " " '
@ "
" ' # # @ J @ +# ) % : & # )
# # ' # D%>E 7 # " # # # $&
&
A
#""